What I Am Reading

In a deeply personal essay, Wayne Mueller, a colleague and friend weaves together story of his father’s final days with a passionate look at Catholic education’s enduring value. faith. At its core, his message is simple yet profound: while the world has changed dramatically since his father’s schooldays in the 1930s, the fundamental mission of Catholic education—preparing souls for their eternal destiny—remains more vital than ever. These institutions play an irreplaceable role in conveying Truth, Beauty, and Goodness to future generations.

Why Invest in Catholic Schools?

A Personal Story By Wayne Mueller

During the final 18 months of my father’s life on earth, I was privileged to encounter wisdom in the midst of suffering.  My father’s brain had been ravaged by dementia.  His once-vibrant mind failed to recognize his children and failed to fulfill the most basic tasks of daily living.  It was painful to observe my father in such a diminished state.  It was a stark reminder that our earthly journey is fleeting.  The wisdom of “memento mori” (a Latin phrase meaning “remember you must die”) was crystal clear.    

Ultimately, the only concept that matters is our eternal destiny.  This destiny is determined by our relationship with Jesus Christ.  

The eternal destiny of souls is why we need to invest in Catholic Schools.  The unique capacity of Catholic Schools to convey Truth, Beauty, and Goodness to the next generation of souls is powerful and irreplaceable.   

Allow me to continue with the story of my father.  He grew up in a rural farming community in southern Indiana during the 1930’s and 1940’s.  My father attended St. Mary of the Immaculate Conception School, which was originally founded in 1880.   

My father learned to love his Catholic faith at St. Mary’s.  In his adult years, my father filled many important leadership roles within his parish and diocese.  He faithfully attended Mass.  He insisted on sacrificing to send his sons to Catholic schools.  Thus, I attended 12 years of Catholic School during the 1970’s and 1980’s.  

Times have drastically changed since the 1930’s right?  Maybe our Catholic schools are no longer relevant? Maybe our Catholic schools are just a piece of nostalgia from the past?  Indeed, our Western culture has progressed with a vast array of technology and inventions during the past century.  The progress of our culture, though, will never supersede the ultimate question of our eternal destiny.  

The relevance of Catholic schools is even greater during the 21st century.  As Western culture strives to eliminate the saving message of Jesus Christ, we must strengthen our resolve to elevate Catholic education.  As Western culture actively attacks the traditional family and the sanctity of life, we must invest more deeply in Catholic schools.

I financially support Catholic schools in Lansing, Michigan – where I grew up – and Traverse City, Michigan – where I raised my children.  I also offer prayers of thanksgiving for these schools and that beautiful St. Mary of the Immaculate Conception School in southern Indiana.  

Nearly 100 years after my father attended this school, the Catholic faith in my family is both intact and vibrant.  I know that my current financial investment in Catholic schools will save souls in the next 100 years.  What else really matters?

If you share this vision for preserving and strengthening Catholic education, Sursum Consulting is here to help. Reach out to us at [email protected] to explore how we can work together to secure your Catholic school’s future and continue this vital mission of formation.

Wayne Mueller has worked since 2004 as the Director of Advancement & Foundation for the Grand Traverse Area Catholic Schools, which faithfully serves over 1,100 students in northern Michigan.

About PATRICK

Patrick Diener is a dynamic leader with a diverse background in philanthropy, nonprofit leadership, and executive coaching. Over the past two decades, Patrick has successfully driven growth for organizations ranging from international NGOs to small Catholic parishes, delivering strategic solutions that align with mission, values, and long-term sustainability. Recognized for his innovative approach to fundraising and business development—rooted in both theology and psychology—Patrick brings a deep understanding of how faith and philanthropy intersect, ensuring that all initiatives are mission-driven and spiritually grounded.

Patrick has held several executive leadership roles, both in consulting and leading fundraising operations for a variety of successful nonprofits. From spearheading large diocesan and university capital campaigns to managing the fundraising at multiple nonprofit organizations, Patrick has consistently delivered strong outcomes. His expertise in building and training high-performing teams has enabled organizations to surpass fundraising goals, secure major gifts, and strengthen long-term donor relationships. Patrick’s hands-on leadership style and strategic vision have empowered nonprofits to grow in scale, mission impact, and financial sustainability.

Additionally, Patrick founded the Institute for Catholic Philanthropy at the University of Mary, a pioneering certificate and MBA program that equips Catholic fundraising professionals with the tools they need for success, rooting best practices in philanthropy within the Catholic faith. This program is recognized for providing fundraisers with a deep, faith-based approach while delivering practical skills that align with the unique needs of Catholic organizations.

Patrick resides in Cheshire, CT with his wife Kathryn and their six children.  They are active parishioners at Blessed Michael McGivney Parish in New Haven. In his spare time, Patrick enjoys skiing, photography, and running an amateur sugaring operation on his historic micro-farm.

Education

  • UNC Charlotte, B.A., Anthropology
  • Pontifical John Paul II Institute for Marriage and Family Studies at the Catholic University of America, M.T.S., Sacred Theology
  • University of Southern Mississippi, Post Grad Studies, Systems Theory
    Association of Fundraising Professionals (AFP)
  • Master Trainer
    Certified Fundraising Executive (CFRE)

Community Involvement

  • Legatus Member, Fairfield CT Chapter

  • Member, Council 1, Knights of Columbus  

     

About Dave

Dave Cook is an entrepreneurial non-profit leader devoted to helping missions reach their full potential. He has served in myriad executive and development roles over a 20-year career. He is animated by his faith and enjoys exploring new and creative ways to promote human flourishing.

Dave is a graduate of the University of Notre Dame with a bachelors in mathematics and philosophy. He later attained an MBA at George Mason University. Throughout his career, he has applied best practices in entrepreneurship and business to the non-profit world. As Director of Programs at the Youth Leadership Foundation, he more than doubled program capacity and helped YLF be recognized as one of the “Best Non-Profits in the Greater Washington Area” by the Catalogue for Philanthropy. He went on to serve as Executive Director for YLF, establishing the organization’s first annual giving program and securing coverage for YLF’s programs on national television.

Dave’s first foray into the diocesan world was as Director of Operations and Stewardship for a Catholic parish in the Diocese of Arlington, Virginia. Overseeing all the temporal activities of the church and school, Dave expanded ministry volunteerism, improved school enrollment and initiated multiple capital improvement projects, among other managerial duties. Eventually, Dave moved across the Potomac River to become Director of the Annual Appeal for the Archdiocese of Washington, where he navigated the covid-19 pandemic through novel digital and integrated marketing forms of donor outreach, inspiring nearly 30,000 gifts and $11 million in donations per year from the local faithful to support archdiocesan ministries. He then expanded his horizons internationally, serving as Executive Director for World Villages for Children, the North American development arm of the Sisters of Mary of Banneux, a religious order committed to lifting children out of poverty.

Dave’s past volunteer service includes membership on the Diocese of Arlington Pastoral Council, the Board of Directors for the International Catholic Stewardship Council and the Board of Directors for the Youth Leadership Foundation. He currently serves as Finance Council Chair for Queen of Apostles Catholic Church in Alexandria, Virginia. He is also a Knight of Columbus, Eucharistic adorer, lector, basketball coach and men’s group leader at his parish. Dave is a devoted husband and father of six children. He enjoys spending time with family and friends, playing basketball and golf, and watching his beloved Fighting Irish on TV on Fall Saturdays.

 

Education

  • Notre Dame, M.S., Mathematics & Philosophy
  • George Mason University, MBA

Community Involvement

  • Youth Leadership Foundation – Director of Programs
  • World Villages for Children, Executive Director